First off: Holy thread necromancy Batman!!! (I'd feel stupider than I do right now if I'd made a new one)
Second: Currently at the Snowpeak ruins, got the pumkin but stuck in some courtyard. I have only a few things wrong with this game:
-The bosses so far are too easy for a Zelda game (either that or I'm just too damn smart for my own good). Except the bone dragon dude, the second part of it was fun and hard.
-You can't bash doors open as a wolf, I know dogs that can open closed doors with their paws

-It now takes 5 pieces of heart to make a full one (and I've noticed they seem to be easier to find, I have 11 hearts and I'm only on the 5th dungeon).
-L-targeting automatically raises your shield, it feels like they're dumbing it down.
So far, it's better than Ocarina of Time. Also easier, but then I was around 9 when I played OoT, so maybe I can actually think now. This is supported by the fact that the Master Quest version, which is supposedly harder, I seem to be finding very easy. Even the Water Temple, which was the most confusing dungeon after the Shadow Temple. Also haven't got to the Shadow Temple on MQ, I got stuck in the well and then lent the disc to my girlfriend, she's determined she'll get past the well before me

(which is quite likely since she got to Dodongo's Cavern really quickly and I have no way of getting any further than the well right now

)
Anyone else find the cut-scene after you free Lanayru from the twilight really disturbing? That was the freakiest thing I've ever seen in a non-Eternal Darkness game (but then again I never play horror games).